Thud! Thud! Thud! Thud! Thud!
What’s that Andy?
It’s me banging my head against the desk…
There’s a story about the Beskpoke project on Hold the front page. I was interested in it as (full disclosure) my Uni is one of the partners in the project. Inevitably I got sucked in to the comments.
But just to put things in to context:
The project has been established to look at the issue of digital and social exclusion in the Fishwick and Callon areas of Preston.
Broadly speaking, the project has two parts. The first is for us to set up a team of community/citizen journalists who will report on the issues that are important to them and to their local community.
The second part of the project is centred on innovative design. Partner universities (Dundee, Falmouth, Newcastle, Surrey, and UCLan) will use the news stories, as well as other information gathered during the lifespan of the project, to design digital technologies that can meet the needs of the area. This collaboration between emotive, technological and functional design with hyper-local journalism is a ground-breaking exercise and, as far as we’re aware, has never been tried before.
Hold the Front page focus on the journalism aspect
The group of citizen journalists were trained as part of a project called Bespoke, a scheme that sees members of the public in Preston provided with flip cameras, mobile phones and journalism training in order to generate their own news stories.
Lots of comment but they are all of a type. One that stood out began:
Years of training, university degrees, shorthand classes ad infinitum.
And the reward? Local nosey parkers with mobile phones are netting page leads.
Given the usual anti-degree tone that pervades it was nice to see degrees get a mention.
Traffic Chaos continues:
So-called citizen journalism should not extend beyond a phone call or submission of on-the-spot footage to the nearest newsroom.
There’s really no such thing as citizen journalism outside of the egotistical “blogosphere”, populated by keyboard warriors and bigots who feel they can do a better job than anybody else at everything – especially the news.
Hmm. I think they actually mean that the term Cit-j has little or no meaning outside a limited circle of egotistical journalists. But everyone is allowed a view (except it seems local nosey-parkers!)
You wouldn’t call a citizen-MD would you?
Update: Jon Walker tweeted to suggest that the phrase MD related to managing director, not Medical doctor.
My response is Doh!
Of course you can’t mention Cit-j without a hackneyed and inappropriate comparison. Hacked off duly obliges
Can’t wait for the day they introduce Citizen MDs thus clearing out an entire layer of over-paid fools and replacing them with an entire layer of fools for free. A great comment that: a) conflates journalism with medicine – because they are exactly the same aren’t they. b) insults journalists as well as the apparent cit-j’s in such a short space – nice work!
The general tone of the comments is to wonder what impact this will have on the journos at the LEP. I don’t want to play down the plight of shrinking regional newsrooms for one minute. Or belittle those who lose jobs. But to see one as a cause of the other is a leap.
Room for all
About the same time that the LEP published it’s first newspaper (1886) my great-grandad borrowed money to buy his first house. He didn’t go to the bank, he went to the butcher. The local butcher! (We have the receipt to prove it.) Would the butcher have advertised that service in the LEP? Not sure. No doubt a local nosey parker would have told him. Oh and if that butcher had sold him a dodgy steak the chance are, nearly 60 years before the NHS he wouldn’t have gone to a doctor.
That’s how my great-grandad’s community worked. It’s how communities still work. Not on definitions of professional pratcice but on people who have the means and the skills doing the jobs that need doing.
My point to hacked-off and traffic chaos would be that there is a world outside the newsroom, full of people who do and discover in different ways. They’ve done it that way before you and they will do it that way after you. You only play a role in a community if you are part of it. Please don’t contribute to an attitude that means they chose to do it without you.
And here is that sentiment in morse code…
Thud! Thud! Thud! Thud!…